What survived the 2024 vacatur of the private fund rules, what the September 2026 risk alert found, and when an independent law firm should conduct or assess the review.
Why the Annual Compliance Review Matters in 2026
For an SEC-registered investment adviser (RIA), the annual compliance review is a legal obligation and a yearly test of whether management is willing to look for weaknesses in its own business. It is not a year-end certification exercise. An adviser can have a well-written manual, a diligent chief compliance officer (CCO) and a history of clean examinations and still miss a fee calculation error, an undisclosed compensation arrangement or a trading practice that contradicts its disclosures. On September 14, 2026, the SEC’s Division of Examinations published a risk alert (the 2026 Risk Alert) describing advisers that skipped review periods, reviewed obsolete procedures, failed to keep testing records and left known problems unresolved.1 This alert explains what Rule 206(4)-7 requires, what the staff is finding, what the recordkeeping obligation looks like after the Fifth Circuit’s 2024 decision, and when an adviser should consider having securities regulatory counsel perform or independently assess the review.
In short, Rule 206(4)-7 under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 requires every SEC-registered investment adviser to adopt written compliance policies and procedures, review them at least annually for adequacy and effectiveness, and designate a CCO to administer them. Rule 204-2(a)(17)(ii) requires the adviser to keep records documenting that annual review.
Key Takeaways for RIAs and CCOs
- The rule has two parts, and most reviews address only one. Rule 206(4)-7(b) requires a review of the adequacy of the policies and the effectiveness of their implementation. Confirming that the manual covers a topic is not a review of whether the control worked.
- Attestations and training are not a review. The 2026 Risk Alert identifies their use as a substitute for the annual assessment as a deficiency.
- Records of the review must still be kept. The 2023 amendment requiring written documentation was vacated, but Rule 204-2(a)(17)(ii) continues to require records documenting the review.
- Repeat findings draw attention. The staff described advisers that received deficiency letters on annual reviews and did not fix the problem.
- No rule requires outside counsel, but independence is the point of the review. The person who built and runs the controls is the least able to grade them. A third party, and in particular a securities law firm, brings independence, legal judgment, the ability to structure legal advice so it can be privileged, and an examination-ready record that an internal review or a checklist vendor cannot.
- Privilege is not automatic. A review file created to satisfy a recordkeeping obligation is producible. Legal advice about the findings can be protected if the engagement is structured for that purpose.
Background: What Rule 206(4)-7 Requires
The rule has three components. Paragraph (a) requires an adviser registered or required to be registered with the SEC to adopt and implement written policies and procedures reasonably designed to prevent violations of the Advisers Act and its rules by the adviser and its supervised persons. Paragraph (b) requires a review, no less frequently than annually, of the adequacy of those policies and procedures and the effectiveness of their implementation. Paragraph (c) requires the adviser to designate a supervised person as chief compliance officer to administer them. The CCO keeps that administrative responsibility whether or not counsel performs the review.2
In the 2003 adopting release, the Commission declined to prescribe a standard manual or a standard review method. Each adviser must identify its own conflicts and compliance risks and design procedures that fit its operations. The release describes a program meant to prevent violations, detect those that occur and correct them promptly. The annual review should consider compliance matters that arose during the prior year, changes in the business of the adviser or its affiliates, and changes in the law, and the release notes that significant compliance events may call for an interim review.3 The Commission considered and declined to require third-party compliance reviews, but it described them as potentially “a useful supplement to our examination program.” These are explanations of the rule, not a mandate to buy any particular outside service, and they leave the choice of reviewer to the adviser.
An annual review is not the same as annual employee attestations, training attendance or the CCO’s day-to-day monitoring. Each can supply evidence for the review, but none of them shows that the adviser evaluated whether its controls were suitable and worked. A review that confirms the manual contains a policy on a subject has not asked whether the policy matches the business or whether the records show it was followed.
What the SEC’s September 2026 Risk Alert on Annual Compliance Reviews Found
The staff observed advisers that reviewed 2021 and 2023 but not 2022, reviews that covered periods longer than twelve months, and advisers that treated training or attestations as the review. It also described advisers that had received a prior deficiency letter on this subject and had not corrected the problem.4 Other firms had written review procedures and did not follow them: the procedures called for specified testing, workpapers or a defined review period, and the file had none of those things. Some tested superseded manuals rather than the procedures in effect during the period, which can produce a polished report about controls the firm was not using.
The staff also found reviews that missed real gaps between policy and practice: fee methodologies inconsistent with agreements or Form ADV, missed breakpoints and refunds, proxy voting descriptions that did not match what the firm did, custody omissions, marketing procedures never updated for the Marketing Rule, and no procedure for overseeing outsourced functions. Some reports stated that corrective measures were complete when the underlying problem continued. The same themes appear in the staff’s 2020 risk alert on compliance programs, which described advisers that could not show any review had occurred and reviews that did not address conflicts or the protection of client assets.5 These examples are where an independent reviewer earns its fee. Comparing contractual obligations, regulatory disclosures and actual transactions against the policies that are supposed to govern them is usually how a compliance problem first becomes visible. A reviewer who relies on management representations or an unchanged checklist can miss it.
Rule 204-2 Recordkeeping After the Fifth Circuit’s 2024 Vacatur
Rule 204-2(a)(17)(ii) requires an adviser to keep records documenting its annual review. The SEC’s 2023 private fund rulemaking would have added an express written documentation requirement to Rule 206(4)-7 itself. The Fifth Circuit vacated that rulemaking in National Association of Private Fund Managers v. SEC, and the SEC has confirmed that the 2023 amendments to Rules 204-2 and 206(4)-7 are no longer in effect. The review requirement and the recordkeeping requirement that existed before 2023 remain.6
Two mistakes follow from getting this wrong. One is telling an adviser that the vacated amendment still binds it. The other is suggesting that no records of the review need be kept. In practice, a dated review memorandum supported by testing records, exception analyses, interview notes, management responses and a corrective action log is a far better file than an unsigned checklist, and the scope of the file should match the work actually done. A firm should never create workpapers after the fact or describe testing that did not occur. If the review finds a deficiency, the file should say what was found, the period affected, who decided what to do about it, the corrective measure and its status. Where a finding calls for privileged legal advice, counsel should structure that advice deliberately rather than assume the review file is protected.
When Outside Counsel Should Conduct or Assess an RIA Compliance Review
A law firm brings something a software checklist or an internal policy update does not. The CCO usually knows the business better than any outside reviewer, but the CCO may also have drafted the procedures, approved the exceptions, handled the last exam and taken part in the decisions now being tested. Independent counsel can look at those decisions without treating past practice as proof of compliance. That says nothing about the CCO’s competence. Evaluating one’s own controls is an ordinary governance problem, and it has an ordinary solution.
Why legal analysis matters
Legal analysis matters because many findings are not procedural. Whether an arrangement is a material conflict that must be disclosed, whether a fee calculation contradicts the advisory agreement, whether the adviser has custody under Rule 206(4)-2, and whether a presentation complies with Rule 206(4)-1 depend on the law applied to the facts. The staff’s June 2026 risk alert on economic conflicts, which describes undisclosed cash sweep revenue, fees charged on cash and unrefunded prepaid fees, is a catalogue of exactly those questions.7 Counsel can distinguish a violation from an operational improvement and advise on client remediation, corrective disclosure and whether to self-report, a decision on which the Commission’s own cooperation framework rewards firms that find and fix problems before the staff does. A review that calls every imperfection a violation is no more useful than one that overlooks the real ones.
Counsel who has served as an RIA CCO can also test whether a proposed fix will work. “Enhance supervision” is not an implementation plan. The adviser needs to know who will perform the control, what record will show it was done, how often, which exceptions get escalated and who verifies closure. Recommendations should be ones the firm’s own people can carry out and the next review can measure.
Events that call for an outside review
Outside review is most useful after a CCO transition, an acquisition, the launch of a private fund or ETF strategy, a change in custodial or trading arrangements, a material expansion of marketing, a prior deficiency, a billing problem or a cybersecurity incident. In each case the question is whether the compliance program kept pace with the business. Counsel can also help management decide whether a targeted review is warranted before the next annual cycle.
Why a third party, and why a law firm
The argument for a third party starts with who examiners expect to see. The first of the annual-review questions that SEC examination staff member Gene Gohlke described in 2006 (discussed below) is who conducted the review, and an answer of “the CCO, reviewing the CCO’s own work” invites the next question. The staff’s 2015 risk alert on outsourced CCOs made the same point from the examiner’s side: reviews were less reliable where the reviewer “relied wholly on the firm to select the records subject to their review,” and the staff found “a general lack of documentation evidencing the testing.” It also described outsourced CCOs who used generic checklists and questionnaires that did not capture the firm’s actual risks.8 An independent reviewer who pulls its own samples, interviews people outside the compliance department and reaches conclusions it does not have to defend from last year is the answer to both concerns.
Not every third party offers the same thing. A compliance consultant brings testing capacity and templates, but a consultant’s report is generally not privileged, and the consultant’s conclusions about whether a practice violates the Advisers Act are, at best, informed opinion. Compliance software can organize a calendar and store attestations; it cannot tell management whether a fee arrangement breaches a contract. A securities law firm can do what neither can. It can give a legal opinion on whether a finding is a violation, decide with management what remediation and disclosure the law requires, structure the privileged part of the work so that it stays privileged, retain consultants under Kovel where specialized testing is needed, and then stand behind the review when the examination team asks about it.9
What to look for in a law firm
The choice of law firm matters as well. The review should be led by a firm that provides both legal and compliance services to registered advisers, with lawyers who have administered compliance programs themselves and who know how an examination unfolds: former SEC or FINRA staff, former chief compliance officers, and lawyers who continue to serve as outsourced CCOs for registered firms. A reviewer with that background knows which records examiners request on the first day, what a credible testing file looks like, how a deficiency letter is written and which findings become enforcement referrals. The review is scoped to the adviser’s actual business rather than a template, the testing is done by the lawyers rather than delegated to a questionnaire, and the same lawyers who conducted the review are available to answer for it when the request letter arrives.
Case study: Pekin Singer Strauss
There is also a reason that has nothing to do with examiners. A review delivered by outside counsel to senior management or the board gets attention and budget that an internal memo often does not. Pekin Singer Strauss shows what happens without that. The firm’s CCO, who was also its CFO and could devote only between 10% and 20% of his time to compliance matters, repeatedly asked the president for help with the annual review and warned that the firm was not ready for an SEC examination. The president turned down one consultant as too expensive and narrowed another engagement to limited trade testing. Nearly three years passed between annual reviews. The firm paid $150,000, and the president was suspended for twelve months from compliance and supervisory roles and paid $45,000. The CCO was not charged.10 For the CCO, an independent review is also a contemporaneous record of diligence. The Division of Enforcement has said that CCOs “should not fear enforcement action if they perform their responsibilities diligently, in good faith,” and has described the CCO cases it brings as those involving participation in misconduct, misleading the staff, or “a wholesale failure to carry out” compliance responsibilities. A review conducted with counsel, acted on and documented is the clearest evidence a CCO can have that none of those descriptions applies.11
When an internal review is enough
A smaller adviser with straightforward operations, an experienced CCO, current policies, credible testing and no material changes can conduct an effective review internally, and the rule permits it. Outside counsel is not a regulatory prerequisite, and no firm should buy a review whose methodology is weaker than its existing program. Counsel becomes more valuable where legal interpretation is central, the CCO’s own decisions are under review, or the firm has repeat findings, significant conflicts, private funds, custody, multiple affiliates, a complex fee structure or a pending examination. Some firms will want counsel to conduct the whole review. Others get the same benefit from targeted legal testing and an independent read of an internally prepared report. Fees should follow scope: the engagement letter should define the business units and review period, the sample testing, the deliverables and exclusions, who collects the records and how significant issues will be escalated.
What a Counsel-Led Annual Compliance Review Should Include
Scoping the review
The engagement starts with a defined scope. Counsel should obtain the current and historical compliance manuals, prior review files, Form ADV Parts 1 and 2, Form CRS where applicable, advisory agreements, organizational and affiliate information, recent regulatory correspondence, compliance calendars and exception reports, then identify what changed in the business during the period and which obligations apply to the firm’s clients, strategies and services.
Risk assessment and testing
A risk assessment comes next. An adviser managing ETFs presents different risks from one managing separately managed accounts, retirement clients or private funds. Counsel should identify the activities that generate conflicts or regulatory exposure and allocate testing accordingly, which is the approach the Adopting Release describes.12 Testing should then go beyond reading policies. For fees, select accounts and recompute charges against agreements, disclosures and billing records, including breakpoints, proration and termination adjustments. For trading, examine allocations, best execution reviews, restricted list controls, personal trading and any soft dollar arrangements. For marketing, compare actual advertisements and their substantiation with Rule 206(4)-1, Form ADV and the firm’s approval procedures. The file should explain how samples were chosen and why.
Custody, private funds, retail clients and service providers
Where custody is in question, the review should examine the factual basis for each custody determination, the requirements of Rule 206(4)-2 that apply, and the records supporting any claimed exception or alternative. For private fund advisers, the review should cover fee and expense allocation, conflicts, valuation, fund documents and compliance with the audited financial statements alternative in Rule 206(4)-2(b)(4), without treating the vacated 2023 rules as if they were in force. For retail advisers, Form CRS, conflicts, advisory agreements, client communications and recommendations will usually be central. For firms that rely on service providers, counsel should confirm which responsibilities the adviser retains and whether its oversight procedures are operating; the 2026 Risk Alert specifically identifies reviews that ignored delegated functions.13 Privacy, information security and business continuity deserve attention in proportion to the firm’s operations and the compliance dates that apply to it. The review should identify which requirements apply to this adviser rather than assume every firm shares the same implementation date.
Interviewing staff
Interviews with the CCO, operations, portfolio management, finance and client-facing staff test whether the written policies describe what people actually do. Counsel should record facts accurately and separate confirmed evidence from statements that still need corroboration. Management should have a chance to correct factual errors before findings are final, but not to erase substantiated exceptions because they are uncomfortable.
The report should tell management what has to change
A useful report identifies the review period, scope, records examined, testing method, material findings, applicable authorities and corrective actions. It separates confirmed violations from control weaknesses, documentation gaps and matters needing further inquiry, and each finding states the facts and why they matter. “Marketing issue” is a label, not a finding. Each corrective measure should have an owner and a target date. Management should document its remediation decisions, including any client refunds, disclosure amendments, policy revisions, supervisory changes or further investigation, and the firm should keep evidence that corrections were completed. A lawyer’s report is not a substitute for implementation, and the 2026 Risk Alert specifically warns against reporting remediation as complete while the problem persists.
Senior management should participate in a way the file can show. In 2006 remarks later posted on the SEC’s website, Gene Gohlke of the examination staff listed the questions examiners ask about an annual review: who conducted it, what was reviewed, when and how, what the findings and recommendations were, the status of implementing them, what documentation was created and kept, and what senior management’s involvement was.14 The remarks are historical staff commentary, but the questions remain a fair test of whether a review file is credible.
SEC Enforcement Actions for Missed Annual Compliance Reviews
The SEC has brought settled proceedings against advisers that did not perform annual reviews.
Hudson Housing Capital (2018)
In 2018, Hudson Housing Capital LLC was found to have failed to review its policies and procedures annually, alongside custody rule failures involving late delivery of audited financial statements to its private funds. The firm consented, without admitting or denying the findings, to a censure and a $65,000 civil penalty.15 The order shows the exposure when a required review is not performed. It does not establish that outside counsel was required or that counsel would have prevented the violations.
Eagan Capital Management (2023)
In 2023, Eagan Capital Management, LLC settled custody rule and compliance rule charges, agreed to a $50,000 penalty and undertook to retain an independent compliance consultant.16 A post-enforcement consultant requirement is not a general obligation to hire outside reviewers. It does show that once failures have been found, independent compliance work can become mandatory, on the staff’s terms. The lesson from both matters is limited. A functioning review process can find weaknesses before an examiner does; it cannot guarantee that a regulator will find no violations. Outside legal review improves issue identification, legal analysis and management accountability. It is not a safe harbor.
The Limits of Attorney-Client Privilege for Compliance Reviews
Engaging a law firm does not cloak the review in privilege. Rule 204-2(a)(17)(ii) requires the firm to keep records documenting the review, and a record created to satisfy an ordinary compliance obligation does not become privileged because a lawyer prepared it. Privilege turns on purpose, participants, confidentiality and the law that applies. A memorandum advising management about a potential violation presents a different question from a routine testing worksheet. Counsel should set clear engagement terms, identify the client, define whether the work includes legal advice, and separate ordinary compliance deliverables from confidential legal advice where appropriate. A privilege legend and copying counsel on email are not enough. Advisers must respond accurately to examination requests and should evaluate any privilege assertion document by document.
Practical Steps Before the Next Annual Compliance Review
- Confirm the date and period of the last completed review and close any gap now.
- Reconcile the current business, client types, affiliates, products and service providers against the manual and Form ADV.
- Give prior SEC findings and unresolved exceptions specific attention.
- Have the reviewer obtain original records rather than summaries prepared by the people who run the controls, and ask the reviewer to identify the tests performed and keep the evidence behind each conclusion.
- Recommendations should distinguish required remediation from discretionary improvements, and the CCO or a designee should maintain a dated corrective action log and verify closure.
- If the review finds a material fee or disclosure problem, get legal advice on client impact, corrective disclosures, possible reimbursement and any separate regulatory obligation before deciding what to do.
Schedule the next review before the deadline, and reassess whether interim testing is warranted after a significant change. A review delivered months late, or a report prepared only because an examiner asked for it, creates its own credibility problem. The best examination file is a record of work completed in the ordinary course.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Rule 206(4)-7 require an independent law firm?
No. The rule requires the adviser to conduct the review and does not specify who performs it. Counsel adds independent legal analysis and testing, which matters most when material conflicts or complex operations are involved.
Why a law firm rather than a compliance consultant?
A consultant can test and report. A law firm can test, report, and give a legal opinion on what the findings mean and what the firm must do about them, and it can structure that advice so it can remain privileged. When the examiners arrive, the lawyers who did the review can explain and defend it. A law firm that also provides compliance services, and whose lawyers have served as regulators and as CCOs, knows which findings matter to the staff and which do not.
Can the CCO perform the review?
Yes. The CCO administers the program and may conduct the review. The adviser should consider an independent assessment where the CCO designed or operates the controls being evaluated.
Does employee training satisfy the requirement?
No. Training and attestations are evidence a review can consider. They do not replace an assessment of whether the policies are adequate and whether they were implemented, and the 2026 Risk Alert treats that substitution as a deficiency.
Must the review be documented?
The 2023 amendment expressly requiring a written review was vacated in 2024. Rule 204-2(a)(17)(ii) still requires the adviser to keep records documenting the review, and a supported written report with workpapers is the practical way to meet it.
Is an annual compliance review checklist enough?
No. The Adopting Release calls for policies and review work tailored to the adviser’s risks. A checklist can organize the work but should not define its scope.
Are attorney-prepared reviews privileged?
Not automatically. Routine compliance records and legal advice are treated differently. Counsel should assess privilege by purpose and by document rather than assume blanket protection.
What happens if the review finds a violation?
Establish the facts, assess the legal and client consequences, decide on remediation and keep an accurate record. Whether disclosure, reimbursement or other action is required depends on the issue.
Can a law firm replace the CCO?
No. Rule 206(4)-7(c) requires a designated supervised person to administer the program. Counsel can test and advise, but management and the CCO keep their responsibilities.
About Robert Moreiro
Robert Moreiro is a Financial Services Partner with Practus, LLP. He has more than 20 years of experience advising broker-dealers, registered investment advisers, financial institutions and associated persons on securities regulation, compliance, regulatory examinations, investigations and enforcement matters. He previously served as Senior Counsel in FINRA’s Enforcement Department and has served as Chief Compliance Officer and AML Compliance Officer for regulated financial-services firms. He is recognized in the 2025 and 2026 editions of The Best Lawyers in America for Securities Regulation and holds the Investment Adviser Certified Compliance Professional and Certified Securities Compliance Professional designations.
- SEC Division of Examinations, Risk Alert, Examinations Observations Regarding Investment Adviser Annual Compliance Reviews (Sept. 14, 2026) (the “2026 Risk Alert”). The Risk Alert reflects staff views and has no legal force or effect. ↩︎
- 17 C.F.R. § 275.206(4)-7(a)-(c). ↩︎
- Compliance Programs of Investment Companies and Investment Advisers, Advisers Act Release No. 2204, 68 Fed. Reg. 74714 (Dec. 24, 2003) (the “Adopting Release”). ↩︎
- 2026 Risk Alert, supra note 1. ↩︎
- SEC Office of Compliance Inspections and Examinations, Risk Alert, OCIE Observations: Investment Adviser Compliance Programs (Nov. 19, 2020). ↩︎
- 17 C.F.R. § 275.204-2(a)(17)(ii); National Ass’n of Private Fund Managers v. SEC, 103 F.4th 1097 (5th Cir. 2024); SEC, Announcement Regarding the Private Fund Advisers Rules (Oct. 31, 2024). ↩︎
- SEC Division of Examinations, Risk Alert, Examinations Observations of Investment Adviser Obligations Related to Economic Conflicts of Interest (June 9, 2026); Report of Investigation Pursuant to Section 21(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and Commission Statement on the Relationship of Cooperation to Agency Enforcement Decisions, Exchange Act Release No. 44969 (Oct. 23, 2001). ↩︎
- SEC Office of Compliance Inspections and Examinations, Risk Alert, Examinations of Advisers and Funds That Outsource Their Chief Compliance Officers (Nov. 9, 2015). ↩︎
- United States v. Kovel, 296 F.2d 918 (2d Cir. 1961); Upjohn Co. v. United States, 449 U.S. 383 (1981); In re Kellogg Brown & Root, Inc., 756 F.3d 754 (D.C. Cir. 2014) (internal review privileged where obtaining or providing legal advice was “one of the significant purposes” of the review). ↩︎
- Pekin Singer Strauss Asset Management Inc., Advisers Act Release No. 4126 (June 23, 2015) (settled order). ↩︎
- Andrew Ceresney, Director, Division of Enforcement, Keynote Address at the 2015 National Society of Compliance Professionals National Conference (Nov. 4, 2015); see also Commissioner Daniel M. Gallagher, Statement on Recent SEC Settlements Charging Chief Compliance Officers With Violations of Investment Advisers Act Rule 206(4)-7 (June 18, 2015). ↩︎
- Adopting Release, supra note 3. ↩︎
- 2026 Risk Alert, supra note 1. ↩︎
- Gene A. Gohlke, Examiner Oversight of “Annual” Reviews Conducted by Advisers and Funds (Apr. 7, 2006) (staff remarks reflecting the author’s views, not those of the Commission). ↩︎
- Hudson Housing Capital LLC, Advisers Act Release No. 5047 (Sept. 25, 2018) (settled order). ↩︎
- Eagan Capital Management, LLC, Advisers Act Release No. 6491 (Dec. 1, 2023) (settled order). ↩︎


